| Platinum | Klein's Seafood |
| Gold | Ken Stewart's Grille |
| Silver | D'Agnese's At White Pond Akron |
| Bronze | Arthur Treacher's Fish & Chips |
| Top Pick | Clearview Inn |
| Top Pick | Kingfish |
| Top Pick | Klein Seafood |
| Top Pick | Lanning's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Moe's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Noisy Oyster Pub |