| Platinum | Winking Lizard |
| Gold | Totally Baked Pizza |
| Silver | Buffalo Wild Wings |
| Bronze | Dontino's Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Finnys Sports Bar and Grille |
| Top Pick | Missing Falls Brewery |
| Top Pick | Mr. G's Pizzeria & Wings |
| Top Pick | Noisy Oyster Pub |
| Top Pick | Pop's Chicken & Waffles |
| Top Pick | Wild Eagle Steak & Saloon Streetsboro |