| Platinum | Diamond Deli |
| Gold | DeVitis Italian Market |
| Silver | Totally Baked Pizza |
| Bronze | Sweet Mary's Bakery |
| Top Pick | Chameleon Cafe Akron |
| Top Pick | Eddie's Cheesesteaks |
| Top Pick | Jersey Mike's |
| Top Pick | Johnny's Diner |
| Top Pick | Missing Falls Brewery |
| Top Pick | The Lockview |