| Platinum | Sweet Mary's Bakery |
| Gold | DeVitis Italian Market |
| Silver | Fat T's Cookies |
| Bronze | Insomnia Cookies |
| Top Pick | Giant Eagle |
| Top Pick | Jubilee Donuts |
| Top Pick | Little Blue Pastry Wagon |
| Top Pick | Reeves Cake Shop |
| Top Pick | Stan's Bakery |
| Top Pick | The West Side Bakery |