| Platinum | Luigis Restaurant |
| Gold | Twisted Tomato |
| Silver | Fiesta Pizza & Chicken |
| Bronze | Gionino's Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | East of Chicago Pizza Company |
| Top Pick | Leeangelo's |
| Top Pick | Leonardo's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Regina's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Rocco's Pizza Shop |
| Top Pick | Upper Crust |