| Platinum | Papa Joe's |
| Gold | Luigis Restaurant |
| Silver | Vaccaro's Trattoria |
| Bronze | D'Agnese's At White Pond Akron |
| Top Pick | Dontino's Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Parasson's Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Pavona's Pizza Joint |
| Top Pick | The Spaghetti Warehouse |
| Top Pick | Upper Crust |
| Top Pick | Vaccaro Trattoria |