| Platinum | The West Side Bakery |
| Gold | Skoops Ice Cream |
| Silver | Sweet Mary's Bakery |
| Bronze | Hartville Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Cold Stone Creamery |
| Top Pick | Dairy Queen |
| Top Pick | Durbin Magic Freeze |
| Top Pick | Sals Gelato |
| Top Pick | Strickland's Frozen Custard |
| Top Pick | Stricklands Frozen Custard |