| Platinum | Old Carolina Barbecue Company - Akron |
| Gold | Waterloo Restaurant & Catering |
| Silver | Waxed Crescent Grazing Co |
| Bronze | Jimmys Johns Worlds Greatest Gourmet Sandwiches |
| Top Pick | Beyond The Bun |
| Top Pick | Catering by Mark Di Feo |
| Top Pick | Difeo's Carry Out |
| Top Pick | Papa Joe's |
| Top Pick | Robert J. Events & Catering |
| Top Pick | Stray Dog |