| Platinum | Nervous Dog Coffee Bar |
| Gold | Sweet Mary's Bakery |
| Silver | Yada Yada Coffee |
| Bronze | Artisan Coffee |
| Top Pick | Cafe Arnone |
| Top Pick | Chameleon Cafe Akron |
| Top Pick | Muggswigz Coffee & Tea |
| Top Pick | Scribbles |
| Top Pick | Stray Dog |
| Top Pick | Therapy Ice Cream and Coffee Bar |